The Lost Are Found
A New Perspective on the Passengers of the Phoenix
by: Mary Risseeuw
As long as I have known the story of the Phoenix
and have been attempting to continue the research
it has been troubling to me that so many on the list had no name. What
a fate to be identified only as 'wife'
or 'child.' An accurate account will never be possible, but many of
the previously unnamed passengers
who were lost have finally regained their identity. Eighty-eight passengers
identified only as wife or child
now have names. Twenty-five others have also been identified as being
passengers lost on the Phoenix
when it went down. I think it is important, even 150 years later, that
these passengers are given the dignity
of their identity.
The office of the shipping company in Cleveland had
only the list of those who sailed from that port. It
was quite natural in those days to take on more passengers at other
ports during the journey. Clerk
Donahue talked of 250 or more as lost. Figures were later obtained
from Captain Benjamin Sweet from
the Buffalo office and probably can be viewed as the closest approximation
known at that time. While it
was quite possible for the surviving crew to be able to accurately
identify those of the crew who were lost
and saved, it is unlikely that all of the cabin and steerage passengers
will ever be identified.
Captain Sweet's estimation of those on board was
a total of 209: 186 passengers (25 cabin and 161 in
steerage) and 23 crew. According to these numbers he claimed 15 crew
members were lost and 8 crew
saved, 21 cabin passengers lost and 4 saved, and 127 steerage passengers
lost and 34 saved. Sweet's list
would give a total of 46 saved and 163 lost.
Beginning in the 1920s, William O. Van Eyck made
a very credible attempt to uncover as much
information as possible on those lost and saved during the burning
of the Phoenix. His notes and papers
were fortunately preserved by the Holland Historical Trust and his
sources can be examined. I have not
been able to ascertain which of his potential contacts here and abroad
never responded to his requests for
information, and one can assume that many of the resources available
today would have been difficult for
Van Eyck to access. Through the use of 14 different sources the following
corrected list of those lost and
saved has been constucted.
CREW LOST
D.W. Kellar, Steward, Cleveland
J.C. Smith, Saloon Keeper, Buffalo
Newell Merril, Second Mate, Ohio City
William Owen,, Second Engineer, Toledo
Hugh Robinson, First Porter, Chicago
John Nugent, First Fireman, Buffalo
Thomas Halsey, Deckhand
George ??, Deckhand
Thomas Fortui, Deckhand, River St. Clair
John and August Murdock, Deckhands, Scotchmen from Canada
Luther Southward, Wheelsman, New Bedford
Horace Tisdale, Cabin Boy
Two Colored Cooks
Total - 15
CREW SAVED
Benjamin G. Sweet, Captain, Cleveland
T.S. Donahue, Clerk, River St. Clair
M.W. House, Engineer, Cleveland
H. Watts, First Mate, Cleveland
A.G. Kelso, Wheelsman, Ohio City
John Mann, Deckhand, Cleveland
E. Watts, Second Porter, Cleveland
Michael O'Brien, Fireman, Buffalo
Total - 8
CABIN AND/OR STEERAGE PASSENGERS LOST
Mr. West, wife and child, Racine
Mr. Fink and wife, Southport (Kenosha)
Mr. Heath and sister, Littleport (Waukegan)
Mrs. J. Long and child, Milwaukee
J. Burrows, Chicago
David Blish, Southport (Kenosha)
Two Misses Hazelton, Sheboygan (daughters of Hiram Hazelton)
Total - 13
CABIN AND/OR STEEERAGE PASSENGERS SAVED
Mr. Long, Milwaukee
Total - 1
HOLLANDERS LOST
WINTERSWIJK
Siebelink, Hendrik Jan b. 23 August 1806 Winterswijk, Reformed
Church,
farmer on De Stroete, Kotten 9
Wife:
Johanna ten Broeke b. 17 May 1803 Winterswijk
Children: Janna Geertruid b. 7 January 1835 Winterswijk
Gerrit Jan b. 17 September 1838 Winterswijk
Servants:
Janna Geertruid Oonk b. 13 May 1828 Winterswijk
Gerrit Jan Grevers b. 16 February 1821 Winterswijk
Janna Geertruid Oonk is listed in the Swierenga ship lists (but
as a daughter) and on the passenger
list of the France (but not as Janna Oonk). This would corroborate
Swierenga's immigration
records listing 4 children. The 2 servants are listed in the
article researched by Henk Voges.
Total - 6 (2 children)
Koffers, Teunis b. 15 January 1795 Winterswijk, Reformed Church,
farmer on Aalberink, Kotten 14
Wife:
Berendina Damkot b. 16 June 1793 Winterswijk
Children: Gerrit Jan b. 18 January 1820 Winterswijk
Tobias b. 26 March 1823 Winterswijk
Janna Berendina b. 6 February 1826 Winterswijk
Jan Willem b. 21 November 1832 Winterswijk
Johanna Hendrika b. 25 May 1835 Winterswijk
The passenger list of the France and Swierenga's ship lists only
list 3 children.
Total - 7 (5 children)
Wilterdink, Derk Jan b. 2 March 1806 Winterswijk, Reformed Church,
farmer on Wilterdink, Kotten 11
Wife:
Hanna Theodora Verink b. 11 November 1815 Winterswijk
Children: Anna Willemina b. 7 May 1842 Winterswijk
Gerrit Hendrik b. 24 July 1845 Winterswijk
The passenger list of the France, Swierenga's ship lists and the
emigration records from
Winterswijk include the following: Widow age 70 (Anna Willemina Wilterdink
b. 17 May 1778
Winterswijk), Jan Willem b. 14 December 1811 Winterswijk, Berendina
age 35, Harman Jan, b.
22 October 1809 Winterswijk
Servant: Gerrit Jan Bloemers b. 3 December 1830 Winterswij
Total - 5 (2 children)
Oonk, Gerrit Jan b. 10 December 1814 Winterswijk, Reformed Church,
farmer on Wilterdinkhuisjen, Kotten 12
Wife: Harmina
Hesselink b. 22 August 1806 Winterswijk
Children:
Jan Willem b. 26 August 1841 Winterswijk
Gerrit Jan b. 9 May 1844 Winterswijk
Total - 4 (2 children)
Sikkink, Jan Albert b. 19 November 1811 Winterswijk, Reformed
Church,
farmer on Pelkwijkhuijsen, Dorpbuurt 110
Wife: Aleida
Weenink b. 8 January 1806 Winterswijk
Children:
Tobias b. 24 February 1835 Winterswijk
Johanna Hendrika b. 3 July 1837 Winterswijk
Jan Derk b. 7 April 1839 Winterswijk
Jan Berend b. 17 September 1842 Winterswijk
Janna Aleida b. 18 April 1846 Winterswijk
Maid:
Dulmers, Theodora Willemina b. 30 April 1817 Winterswijk
Total - 8 (5 children)
Onnink, Hendrik Willem b. 24 February 1818 Winterswijk, Reformed
Church,
farmer on Onnink-huijsen, Ratum 14
Wife:
Hendrika ten Haken b. 3 August 1823 Winterswijk
Children: Janna Geertruid b. 13 April 1843 Winterswijk
Hendrik Jan b. 2 June 1844 Winterswijk
Berendina Willemina b. 21 February 1845 Winterswijk
Servant: Reessink, Jan Hendrik b. 20 January 1828 Winterswijk
Hendrik and his family are not listed on the passenger list of
the France or
in Swierenga's ship lists.
Total - 5 (3 children)
Guerkink, Gerrit Jan b. 11 May 1805 Winterswijk, Reformed Church,
farmer on Gribbroek, Huppel 7 Widower (wife
died 19 April 1844)
Children: Janna Willemina b. 19 January 1826 Winterswijk
Stijntjen b. 6 December 1827 Winterswijk
Janna Berendina b. 3 February 1836 Winterswijk
Jan Hendrik b. 16 June 1838 Winterswijk
Jan Willem b. 21 February 1841 Winterswijk
Total - 6 (5 children)
Kooyers (Koijers), Hendrik Willem b. 6 Februrary 1801 Winterswijk,
Reformed Church,
from Heemink, Huppel 21
Wife: Janna Berendina Wilterdink b. 27 January 1800 Winterswijk
Children: Engelina Johanna b. 25 March 1835 Winterswijk
Berend Willem b. 27 July 1836 Winterswijk
Total - 4 (2 children)
Nijweide, Hendrik Jan b. 16 March 1811 Winterswijk, Reformed Church,
farmer on Vonderhuis, Miste 25
Wife: Dora Gesiena Voskuil b. 12 November 1811 Winterswijk
(sister of Derk Antony Voskuil)
Children: Janna Hendrika b. 1 August 1837 Winterswijk
Jan Willem b. 24 December 1839 Winterswijk
Berendina b. 25 February 1842 Winterswijk
Engelbarts b. 11 November 1843 Winterswijk
Christina b. 18 October 1845 Winterswijk
Total - 7 (5 children)
ten Pas, Johanna Berendina b. 9 March 1809 Winterswijk, Reformed
Church
(wife of Jan Berend Esselinkpas b. 28 November 1810 Winterswijk, farmer
on
Lammershuisjen, Woold 84. Jan died on the ocean voyage aboard the France.)
Children: Steven Jan b. 6 November 1836 Winterswijk
Hendrika b. 14 December 1837 Winterswijk
Janna Geertruid b. 4 August 1840 Winterswijk
Willemina b. 12 February 1842 Winterswijk
Jan Hendrik b. 13 March 1844 Winterswijk
Total - 6 (5 children)
Meenink, Janna Willemina b. 31 March 1813 Winterswijk, Reformed
Church,
(wife of Hendrik Jan Wilterdink from Smalbraak, Huppel 6)
Children: Gerrit Jan Wilterdink b. 29 February 1836 Winterswijk
Janna Gesiena Wilterdink b. 19 April 1838 Winterswijk
Jan Albert Wilterdink b. 4 April 1840 Winterswijk
Berend Willem Wilterdink b. 23 December 1844 Winterswijk
Jan Hendrik Wilterdink b. 3 May 1846 Winterswijk
Total - 6 (5 children)
Damkot, Janna Gesiena b. 19 April 1796 Winterswijk, Reformed Church
(wife of Jan Willem Oonk from Slotboom-Joosthuis, Kotten 11)
Children: Jan Willem Oonk b. 10 January 1821 Winterswijk
Jan Hendrik b. 28 November 1828 -- was a servant of Hendrik
Siebelink
Steven Jan Oonk b. 23 April 1839 Winterswijk
The passenger list of the France lists 6 children and Swierenga's
immigration
lists indicate 5 children.
Total - 4 (3 children)
te Winkel, Tobias Hendrik b. 31 May 1840 Winterswijk
Gerrit Jan b. 16 January 1842 Winterswijk
Janna Geertruida b. 5 April 1844 Winterswijk
Gerrit Willem b. 10 October 1846 Winterswijk
Parents: te Winkel, Gerrit b. 23 January 1803 Winterswijk from
Willink-kempe at Ratum 8, Reformed Church
Wife: Jozina ten Haken b. 25 August 1815 Winterswijk
This family is listed on the France ship list and in Swierenga's
ship lists. In the 1860 census Gerrit
and Jozina are listed as living in the Town of Holland, WI with 3 young
children - Gezina age 7,
Hannah age 5, and Gerrit age 3. It seemed curious that these parents
would have put their 4
young children on board the Phoenix alone, until it was discovered
that also travelling with them
were two younger sisters of Jozina ten Haken. Berendina is listed in
the immigration records as
being a maid and lived at Willink-kempe with the te Winkel family.
ten Haken, Berendina b. 11 October 1820 Winterswijk, maid living
at
Willink-kempe, Ratum 8
ten Haken, Geertruid b. 1 November 1828 Winterswijk from Hijink-pas,
Woold 11
This curious story is cooraborated by the diary of J.D. te Winkel, Winterswijk in January 1848:
Den 8 kregen een brief van mijn broer Gerrit van Buffalo uit Amerika
waaruit bleek alle zijne vier
kinderen benevens verscheiden van zijne reisgenoten reeds dood waren
Verde dat de stoomboot
waarmede de andere afgescheidenen naar West-Consin wilden varen gesprongen
is zoodat er
weinige van zijn geredt.....
"On the 8th we received a letter from my brother Gerrit from Buffalo
in American in which it was
reported that his four children, besides many of his fellow passengers
were dead. Also that the
steamboat with which other seceders planned to go to Wisconsin was
wrecked and few were
rescued..."
Total - 6 (4 children)
AALTEN
Kraayenbrink (Krayenbrink/Krajenbrink), Willem b. 30 September
1810 Dinxperlo
Woodenshoemaker from Lintelo, Reformed Church
Wife: Theodora Krienen b. 10 October 1819 Gendringen
Children: Gerrit Hendrik b. 10 May 1840 Dinxperlo
Johanna b. 3 February 1844 Aalten
Kaatjen b. 30 November 1845 Aalten
Willem and his family are not listed on the passenger list of
the France or in
Swierenga's ship lists.
Total - 5 (3 children)
Navis, Derk Willem b. 26 July 1801 Aalten, Reformed Church,
farmer on Navis, Lintelo 47 (now Navisweg 6)
Wife: Johanna Rexwinkel b. 1 February 1802 Gendringen
Mother: Janna Lieftink b. 29 November 1767 Aalten
(widow of Hendrik Jan Navis)
Children: Hendrika Johanna b. 18 March 1827 Aalten
Gerrit Hendrik b. 22 September 1833 Aalten
Hendrik Jan b. 19 March 1836 Aalten
Geertruid b. 18 July 1839 Aalten
Hendrik Willem b. 1 March 1842 Aalten
Derk and his family are not listed on the passenger list of the
France or in Swierenga's ship lists.
Total - 8 (5 children)
Brusse, Jan b. 25 March 1819 Aalten, farmer on Brusse, Lintelo
66
(now Gendringseweg 44), Reformed Church
Jan is not listed on the passenger list of the France or in Swierenga's
ship lists.
Total - 1
WISCH/VARSSEVELD
Colenbrander, Arend age 32, farmer at Op Vaaghuis, 456 Binnenheurne,
Varsseveld
Seceeder from Christian Reformed Church
Wife:
Christina Gesink age 34
Children: Grada Aleida 13 years b. 1834 Varsseveld
Jan Adolf 10 years b. 1837 Varsseveld
Christina 8 years b. 1839 Varsseveld
Gerrit Jan 6 years b. 1840 Varsseveld
Aaltjen 4 years b. 1843 Varsseveld
Baby b. 1847 Varsseveld
Arend and his family are not listed on the France's passenger
list or in
Swierenga's ship lists. Swierenga's immigration lists and Ligterink's
book indicate 5
children and Van Eyck's listing says 6. They left Holland on 21 August
1847.
Total - 8 (6 children)
Oberink, Lammert b. 8 March 1789, Varsseveld age 49, Christian
Reformed,
farmer/day laborer at 427 Binnenheurne, Varsseveld
Wife: Willemina Hofs b. 26 February 1792, Gendringen
Children: Gerrit Jan b. 20 July 1828, Varsseveld
Grada b. 19 May 1834, Varsseveld
Hendrik Willem b. 13 September 1838, Varsseveld
Evert Jan b. 30 January 1823, Varsseveld
Lammert and his family are not listed on the passenger list of
the France or in Swierenga's ship
lists. They were reportedly in a hurry to leave because Evert Jan was
about to be forced into
military service.
Total - 6 (3 children)
te Kotte, Hendrik Jan age 56, Seceeder from Christian Reformed
Church
farmer/landholder on Op de Profijt at Varsseveld
Wife: Aaltjen Nagel age 55
Children: 4
This information is taken from the Varsseveld immigration records.
Hendrik
and his family are not listed in any other records.
Total - 6 (4 children)
Wildenbeest, Roelof, Reformed Church
Wife:
Berendina Radstake
Child: Dina Johanna Wildenbeest b. 20 January 1841 Dinxperlo
Ligterink lists his age as 36 as a widower with 2 children. In
the emigration records of Dinxperlo
it says that Dina emigrated in September 1847.
Total - 3 (1 child)
Gielink, Dirk wife and child
Total - 3 (1 child)
Nebbelink and family
Approx. Total - 4 (2 children)
Toebes family
Approx. Total - 4 (2 children)
GENDRINGEN
Demkes - Ansink, Catharina from Op den Broekslag
Child: Gerrit Hendrik age 32
Total - 2
OOSTERBEEK
Bruijel, Hendrikus
Wife:
Jeneken Bongers
Children: Dirkje
Hendrina
Geertruy Willemina
Dirk Willem
Total - 6 (4 children)
HOLTEN, OVERIJSSEL
Landeweerd, Hendrik Egbert b. 27 September 1796 Holten, farmer,
Seceeder from
Christian Reformed
Church. Son of Hendrik Egbert Landeweerd and
Hendrina Aaftink.
Wife: Gerritdina
Hakkink b. 8 May 1797 Holten. Daughter of Bernardus
Wilhelmus Hakkink
and Teuntje Wibbelink.
Children: Berend
Willem b. 15 October 1830
Tonia b. 11 February 1833
Egbert b. 10 June 1836
Fenneke b. 16 October 1838
Total - 6 (4 children)
Beumer, Egbert b. 20 Mar 1809 Holten-Dijkerhoek, Bapt: 26 Mar
1809, tailor, Seceeder from
Christian Reformed Church, m. 7 Nov 1840 Holten
Wife:
Harmien Stevens b. 24 May 1809 Holten-Dijkerhoek Bapt:
28 May 1809, daughter of Barteld Stevens and Jenneken Teunissen
Schouwenberg
Child: Janna b. 4 Jan 1844 Holten-Dijkerhoek
(Another child, Jenneken was b. 1 Oct 1846 and d. 12 Oct 1846)
On the passenger list for the France and in Swierenga's ship lists
there lists a Teunis Beumer
travelling with Egbert and his family. Teunis was a step-brother of
Egbert. Their father was Jan
Beumer from Markelo. Jan was Bapt. 1771 Markelo and married 1) Teuntje
Janssen who died
1796 in Holten . Jan married 2) Jenneken Janssen Kappers b. Laren to
Jan Kappers and Enneken
Kranengouw.
Beumer, Teunis b. 23 Feb 1797 Holten-Dijkerjoek, a tailor, Seceeder
from Christian
Reformed Church
Total - 4 (1 child)
WIERDEN/ENTER, OVERIJSSEL
Hommers, Gerrit Jan Bapt: 25 Dec 1788 Wierden/Enter, farmer on
"de Keijzer"
(the Emperor), Seceeder from Christian Reformed Church, Widower (m.
Aleida Zweers in 1818. She was bapt 2 Mar 1789 Wierden/Enter and died 10
June
1837. Aleida was married first to Berend Jan Hommers and the Jan Hommers
travelling with Gerrit was his step-child. She was the daughter of Gerrit
Zweers
and Hendrika Lubbers). Gerrit was the son of Wilm Hommers and Jenneken
Hagreize.
Children: Hendrikus, b. 23 May 1835 Wierden/Enter
Gerrit, b. 25 Oct 1830 Wierden/Enter
Jan, b. 1814 Wierden/Enter
When Hommers left Holland he sold his farm, which consisted of
a house, a barn, approximately
15 acres of farmland an 20 acres of hayland; so he would have been
considered well-to-do.
Gerrit's children and step-son are incorrectly identified as Lubbers
in France passenger list. Gerrit
and Aleida also had a daughter Berendina b. 6 June 1829 Wierden/Enter
who married Jan Hendrik
te Brinke in 1847. A daughter Hendrika was b. 23 Sept 1821 Wierden/Enter
and d. 6 Jan 1824.
Willemina was b. 2 Nov 1839 Wierden/Enter and d. 7 Jun 1835
Total - 4 (3 children)
Lubbers, Hendrikus b. 17 Sep 1806 Wierden/Enter, Bapt: 21 Sep
1806, shoemaker,
Seceeder from Christian Reformed Church. Hendrikus was the son of Jan
Anthonissen Lubbers and Hendrika de Wilde. He married 30 Jan 1840 in
Wierden.
Wife: Maria (Marijke) Lubbers b. 1801 m. 1840 Maria was
the daughter of Lucas Lubbertsen Lubbers and Leida Kattelaar.
Children: Hendrik (Hein) b. 18 May 1841 Wierden/Enter
Lucas b. 31 Jan 1843 Wierden/Enter
Total - 4 (2 children)
Geerlings, Willem (Wilhelm) b. 10 May 1830
Geerlings, Hendrikje (Wilhelmina) b. 18 January 1833
Total - 2 children
APPROXIMATE NUMBER OF DUTCHMEN LOST - 151
APPROXIMATE NUMBER OF DUTCH CHILDREN LOST - 92
HOLLANDERS SAVED
WINTERSWIJK
Esselinkpas, Hendrik Jan b. 22 December 1812 Winterswijk
From Maathuis, Kotten 82 d. 13 October 1901
Willink, Berendina b. 5 April 1811 Winterswijk
from Haverkamp, Kotten 80
Wilterdink, Hendrik Jan b. 19 May 1807 Winterswijk
from Smalbraak, Huppel 6 d. 10 September 1891
ten Dolle, Willemina b. 25 July 1829 Winterswijk d. 24 May 1914
Oonk, Jan Willem b. 8 July 1795 Winterswijk d. 1870?
farmer on Stotboom-Joosthuis, Kotten 10
Oonk, Johanna b. 1 September 1825 Winterswijk d. 9 July 1853
Oonk, Harmina b. 19 January 1832 Winterswijk d. 10 June 1904
Oonk, Janna Hendrika b. 17 February 1835 Winterswijk d. 17 December 1903
Reuselink, Harmen Jan b. 4 September 1815 Winterswijk d. 10 July
1896
from Meerdink-Nijhuis, Woold 55
Voskuil, Dirk Antony b. 11 May 1817 Winterswijk d. 8 February
1901
from Voskuil, Miste 57
Total - 10
VARSSEVELD
Oberink, Geeritje b. 27 May 1825 d. 15 October 1858
Total - 1
HOLTEN, OVERIJSEL
Schuppert, Teunis d. 21 September 1856
Wife: Gerdina (Hendrina) Landeweerd d. 10 May 1848
Child: Dena Johanna Schuppert b. 9 August 1845 d. 7 October 1916
Landeweerd, Hendrika b. 3 December 1827 d. 1884
Wissink, Berend Jan b. 1813 d. 1886
Wife: Teuntje Landeweerd b. 1825 d. 10 January 1857
Landeweerd, Hanna Gerdina b. 1844 d. 3 December 1915
Total - 7
WIERDEN/ENTER
Geerlings, Gerrit b. 26 December 1802 Meppel, Drenthe Bapt 1 Jan
1803 Meppel
d. 12 July 1886 Occ: Miller/baker/shoemaker. He was the son of Albert Geerlings
& Hendrijke Jacobs Kuijer. They married 10 Mar 1802 in Meppel and Albert
died
before 1825 in Meppel.
Wife:
Aaltje (Eliza) de Vries b. 13 December 1801 Zwolle, Overijssel d. 2 May
1886
She was the daughter of Willem de Vries and Hendrikje van Eelen
Children: Henry (Hendrik John) b. 5 December 1836 Hattem
d. 10 December 1901
Jacob b. 5 May 1839 Hattem d. 7 June 1906
Altje b. 10 December 1842 Apeldoorn d. 11 November 1898
Gerritje b. 13 January 1844 Apeldoorn d. 17 February 1893
Contrary
to all previously published reports, Alberta Geerlings was not on the Phoenix.
Her birth records in the Netherlands indicate that she died in June
of 1847 and this was also
confirmed in a letter written by John Geerlings of Milwaukee (a grandson
of Gerrit and Aaltje) to
William Van Eyck on November 16, 1922.
Total - 6
TOTAL SAVED - 24
SOURCES:
Diary of J.D. te Winkel
Emigratie uit de gemeente Wisch naar Noord-Amerika
Emigration records for Dinxperlo: 1830-1930
Emigration records for Winterswijk: 1846-1915
Emigration records for Varsseveld: 1847
J.H. Wissink, Vlaardingen, Netherlands
Konink, W.J. (1983). Emigratie uit de Gemeente Aalten naar Noord-America:
1830-1930
Kooger, H. Ramp Met Het SS Phoenix: landverhuizers uit de grensstreeek
Ligterink, G.H. (1981). De landverhuizers
Passenger list of the ship France
Swierenga, Robert P. (1987). Dutch emigrants to the United States,
South
Africa, South American & Southeast Asia, 1835-1880
Swierenga, Robert P. (1983). Dutch immigrants in U.S. ship manifests,
1820-
1880
Voges, Henk De Plantenhoektragedie - Kotten 1847
Wilterdink, Willem (1990). Winterswijkse Pioniers in Amerika